Wednesday, March 28, 2012

I told you so

Kevin Drum notes that Mitt Romney really is extraordinarily unpopular compared to candidate major party candidates in past years.

I tell him that I told him so again and again.


This  isn't news.   Romney has had extraordinarily high unfavorables for a while now.  
Once you said this wasn't as true as the media want us to believe (language policing -- "media" is plural "as the media wants you to believe" should be "as the media want you to believe" or "as the medium wants you to believe")http://motherjones.com/kevin-d... I said you were wrong in comments.You wrote that  the unpopularity of Republican 2012 hopefuls was "much more the rule than the exception"http://motherjones.com/kevin-d... I typed in comments that you were wrong.Later you asked if Romney's high unfavorable rating was  normal.  I told you it wasn't http://rjwaldmann.blogspot.it/... 
The extraordinary astounding unique data can't be ignored anymore.  
I love to type "I told you so" but I told you so, again and again.

Drum has noted this before too, but only after I had told him so as I comment in a partially polite second comment.
Of course you have noted Romney's extraordinary unpopularity repeatedly too.  But I was convinced when you were still skeptical.

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Shedding Luce

Brad finds it impossible to disagree with Ed Luce.

I find it possible to disagree with Luce.  He writes "AIDS and other diseases" and "fashionable diseases."  Kim's major accomplishment came in fighting TB not AIDS.  I guess TB is a bit fashionable (the Gates's are interested).  Fighting TB is also very hard as half therapy is much worse than none, because it selects drug resistant TB.  Kim is alleged to have managed to arrange directly observed therapy (making sure people take all the pills) in the third world.

Of course Okonjo-Iweala also has huge extraordinary accomplishments.  Such as ... ?  Luce doesn't mention any.  He notes that she is now powerful and has already held a top position at the World Bank.  Favoring insiders sure doesn't sound "meritocratic" to me.  Others have noted that Okonjo-Iweala is very smart.  Luce doesn't seem to consider that relevant.

It seems to me that Luce decided that Kim is the wrong choice strictly because of his nationality.

I stress that I don't necessarily disagree with Luce's conclusion, nor do I think his reasoning is unsound.  I don't see any reasoning at all.

Friday, March 23, 2012

Mitch a Sketch

Ed Kilgore advises Democrats to not throw their Etch a Sketches away.



I absolutely agree.  In fact, the themes of Romney the ruthless vulture capitalist and Romney the flip-flopper complement each other (even more than Kerrry most liberal flip flopper did).  In each case he can be portrayed as being unscrupulous willing to do anything to get money then or power in 2013.  Each mean he is someone from whom one wouldn't want to buy a used car.

The polling is unclear.  The reason is that Obama has been under attack for years.  Most people haven't begun to examine Romney.  I'm sure they can be convinced by video of him saying one thing and its opposite with the exact same tone and expression (he only has one).  Political junkies consider Romney a totally outstanding flip flopper. We are sometimes leading indicators.  Also, on topics other than his own core beliefs (or the absence of same) Romney lies extraordinarily often even for a politician.

The assertion that Romney is completely unprincipled and untrustworthy has the additional advantage of being true.

Brad at Brookings

The guy was presenting a paper and he had energy to consider other presentations.  How many brains do you think are in that skull.  I guess at least three.

3 Separate Comments

3) on Mamelukes. Huh ?!?!? What about Egypt ?  Yes it is mostly desert, but the people live in the Nile valley -- ground zero for extracting taxes from agriculture.  This is where excess grain beyond that needed to feed the farmers was produced.  This was where farmers couldn't run away and farm somewhat less valuable land under another lord (or no lord).  Or maybe ground zero was Mesopotamia.  The Ibn Kaldun hypothesis makes less than no sense.  It is a common story for the Arabian Peninsula on the one hand and Egypt and Mesopotamia on the other.  But clearly they are the most nearly opposite ecologies in the old world.  Egypt has been under central control or a province of an empire longer than any other place.  Saudi Arabia competes with Afghanistan as the area where empire feared to tread (or didn't bother).  The idea of a border (along with the first geometry) came from Egypt.  Saudi Arabian borders were not defined on maps drawn in my lifetime.  The places to look to test Erich Chaney vs Ibn Kaldun are Egypt and Iraq not Iran. 50 years hah.  The experiment is well under way.

1) Stock Watson and Blinder together say a drop in aggregate demand has about the same effects no matter what the cause.  Keynes would not be surprised by this.  It is a problem for newKeynes (have I mentioned that I think that  newKeynes seems to have more to learn from Keynes than vice versa ?).  To the extent that the dynamics are similar, there is evidence that money isn't so very special after all.  This isn't just trouble for Friedman but for all of his followers, that is all mainstream macro-economists.

2. Gauti et all I like your insistence on fiscal not monetary policy.  Many of my critical comments on this blog were comments on posts in which you discussed useful things the Fed could legally do.  But I didn't disagree 100% then and so I don't agree 100% now.  The Fed can irreversibly expand the money supply if it buys a huge amount of illiquid assets.  This is not good strategy for an investor as one loses huge amounts of money that way.  Ah yes loosing money is irreversibly supplying money.  If the Fed manages to have more liabilities than marked to market assets, then it can't retire the liabilities.  Now this means using open market operations to give money to financiers.  I'd much prefer giving it to ordinary people by cutting T.  I also prefer increased G to reduced T.  But the Fed can commit by trading very badly.

To be serious.  If the Fed buys risky assets there are two benefits. One is the one you have been stressing since 2008, that the supply of risky assets to the private sector is too high and this is the root of the problem.  But the other is that if things go bad, the monetary expansion can't be reversed (can't retire liabilities if your assets aren't worth that much).  So the Fed commits to an irreversible monetary expansion if things go badly.  The fact that it transfers its mark to made up balance sheet profits to the Treasury but the Treasury doesn't give the money back, makes it easy for the Fed to gamble -- win for a while and then get stuck so it can't reduce the money supply when it finally looses.

The problem is that if the economy tanks, then the Fed can't avoid creating high inflation expectations (because it will not be able to retire the huge pile of money).  Is this a bug or a feature ?

This approach is within the Fed's current legal authority.  What's the problem ?

Thursday, March 22, 2012

If you stuck Jon Chait end to end, he would reach a consensus

Jon Chait writes


 Ryan explained that there’s a growing bipartisan consensus that we should close tax deductions and loopholes and lower rates. “What we have here on tax reform is a new emerging consensus,” says Ryan. “The president and his party leaders are outside this consensus even though his own treasury secretary says the better way to go is to broaden the base and lower rates.”
Now, there’s not really a growing consensus that tax reform is good. The consensus has existed among economists forever.

and I throw a cow.

Consensus among economists ?  You must be joking.  I am an economist and I absolutely oppose lowering rates whether or not loopholes are eliminated.  As to loopholes, well it depends.  Should we eliminate the mortgage interest deduction ? Sure (but not yet -- and not quickly -- low housing investment is a problem now).  The deduction for charitable contributions not so much.  Tax employer provided health insurance when the Republicans stop trying to kill Obamacare (that is on the first of never).  Eliminate the R&D tax credit ? Why are you nuts ? Eliminate the investment tax credit ? Why tax reinvested profits at all ?

No one like tax expenditures in the abstract (as almost everyone dislikes high government spending in the abstract).  It is impossible to get a consensus once one discusses which deductions to eliminate.

You have long supported broadening the base and lowering rates.  The economists who basically agree with Paul Ryan have long supported tax reform.  Most non Randian economists do to. But many of us don't.

If you want to claim there is a consensus, show me a poll. Also one on just what should  capital gains tax rates, tax treatment of capital income and top income tax rates.  On the second set of questions, I am willing to bet a small amount of money at even odds that most members of the American Economic Association disagree with Ryan about the direction in which policy should change.

Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Derek Thomson is a bit confused. The graph shows the growth of total real per capta government spending, that is federal plus state plus local. This is explained in the comment thread of Thoma's post.

I think the extreme pattern of state and local might have something to do with property tax revenues, has at least something to do with California being at the limit due to prop 13 and Schwarzenegger, and has a good bit to do with the Republican pickups in State legislatures and governors' mansions in 2010.

In any case it is not reasonable to blame Obama who did most of what he could for state and local governments in the ARRA. Blame Ben Nelson for trimming the fat, frying the bacon and milking the sacred cows (and loving it) instead.

On
http://maddowblog.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/03/20/10779346-forget-what-youve-heard-from-the-gop-about-spending-and-regulations#comments

Monday, March 19, 2012

Over Savings ?

Felix Salmon argues that the growth of US potential output has slowed. Time Duy notes that it is a demand side argument. I note that this isn't a contradiction in terms.

Robert Waldmann said...
I feel like defending Salmon. The idea that "potential" means "supply side" is not tautological. It is a hypothesis. There used to be a lot of economists who were convinced that demand couldn't grow without bound, so growth was permanently limited by demand (Keynes was not one of them). They sure have a lot of egg on their late faces. But they may have been off by only about a century.

The Salmon hypothesis is that people will never find a way to spend the huge incomes that the US top 1% make. So the only way demand can keep growing is for them to loan money to the bottom 99%. But this can't go on forever as default becomes too attractive (or unavoidable). Clearly we can consume more, but not infinitely more and a lot more than now only if income is redistributed.

The fact that this has not been true in the past, doesn't mean it isn't true now. The case against is accidental theory -- extrapolating the trend of consumption (philosophically like extrapolating the trend of house prices or .com valuations). Yes we can write down a utility function so consumption grows at the same rate forever (I did last Friday). We can write down utility functions with any implication we want. But that doesn't mean that the real world works that way.

Personally, I have unbounded faith in the unbounded gluttony of the US consumer, but I have no proof.